Commonwealth ombudsman finds automated aged care assessment tool leading to unfair outcomes - Juniper
Our Stories

Commonwealth ombudsman finds automated aged care assessment tool leading to unfair outcomes

The Commonwealth Ombudsman has found the Federal Government’s automated aged care assessment tool is leading to unfair outcomes, raising serious concerns about transparency, accountability and public confidence in the system.

Juniper has been vocal in calling for an investigation into the Integrated Assessment Tool (IAT). In our submission to the Inquiry into the Transition from the Commonwealth Home Support Program (CHSP) to the new Support at Home Program we raised concerns about the serious consequences of automated “robo-decisions” that cannot be changed, even when they do not accurately reflect an older person’s care needs.

Introduced on 1 November 2025 under the new Aged Care Act, the IAT forms part of the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing’s Single Assessment System. It uses an algorithm to determine whether an older person is eligible for aged care services, their funding level and priority category, or whether they are ineligible for support.

However, Commonwealth Ombudsman Iain Anderson’s report Automation and oversight in aged care, found the tool lacks adequate safeguards and does not allow automated decisions to be overridden, even when the outcome is clinically inappropriate.

Mr Anderson reported the Department had previously advised assessment providers and the public that automated decisions could be changed when this was not the case.

The Ombudsman also found there was no publicly available information explaining how the IAT determines its outcomes, raising concerns about transparency in government decision-making.

Juniper CEO Russell Bricknell said the Ombudsman’s report paints a troubling picture of a system that lacked transparency and accountability from the outset.

“These findings raise serious questions about how these decisions were made, how they were communicated to older Australians and providers and why it took an external investigation to bring these issues to light,” Mr Bricknell said.

“Assessment outcomes have a significant impact on the care and support older Australians can access. It’s essential the systems in place determining those decisions are transparent, evidence-based and are given the appropriate level of oversight.”

The Ombudsman has made 10 recommendations to the Department, including changing legislation to allow automated decisions to be overridden, reviewing the legislation and rules underpinning the algorithm, and ensuring meaningful public consultation on proposed changes.

The Federal Government said it will consider the report carefully, stating it accepts or accepts in principle all remaining recommendations.

Mr Bricknell added the findings reinforced the need for an aged care assessment system that puts older people first and allows decisions to reflect their individual circumstances and clinical needs.

“Automated tools should support informed decision-making, not prevent assessors from intervening when an outcome is clearly wrong,” he said.

“This review provides an opportunity to reset the system because older Australians deserve better than this.”

The Ombudsman’s investigation come as the Inspector-General of Aged Care launches a review into whether the Government’s reforms are delivering the outcomes intended by the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety.

The review will go beyond tracking which recommendations have been implemented to examine whether reforms are effective, appropriate and publicly accountable, and whether further action is needed.

The final report is due to Aged Care Minister Sam Rae by 1 November 2027, providing an important opportunity to assess whether the changes made since the Royal Commission are translating into better outcomes for older Australians.

Juniper’s own Royal Commission Report Card found that while many reforms have progressed, significant gaps remain in translating policy changes into tangible improvements for older Australians, making this review a timely and important piece of work.

Mr Bricknell added: “We cannot afford to slip back into the practices that led to the Aged Care Royal Commission. Nor can we afford to repeat the mistakes of the past. The Royal Commission exposed the consequences of a system that was failing to put older people at the centre of decision making.

“We should also learn from the Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, which showed the devastating consequences that can come with relying too heavily on automated processes without adequate oversight.

“The lessons from both the Aged Care and Robodebt Royal Commissions must be applied to aged care reform. Technology should support, not dictate, decisions about the care and support older Australians need.

“That means a commitment by the Government to transparency and accountability at every level of the system, with decisions open to scrutiny, informed by evidence and focused on delivering better outcomes for older Australians.”